Could sudoku, drugs and a Mediterranean diet help keep our brains fit? What can the latest neuroscience research tell us?
Neuroscience research got a huge boost last week with news of Professor John O'Keefe's Nobel prize
for work on the "brain's internal GPS system". It is an exciting new
part of the giant jigsaw puzzle of our brain and how it functions. But
how does cutting-edge neuroscience research translate into practical
advice about how to pass exams, remember names, tot up household bills
and find where the hell you left the car in a crowded car park?
O'Keefe's prize was awarded jointly with Swedish husband and wife team
Edvard and May-Britt Moser for their discovery of "place and grid cells"
that allow rats to chart where they are. When rats run through a new
environment, these cells show increased activity. The same activity
happens much faster while the rats are asleep, as they replay the new
route.
We already knew that the part of the brain known as the
hippocampus was involved in spatial awareness in birds and mammals, and
this latest work on place cells sheds more light on how we know where we
are and where we're going. In 2000, researchers at University College London
led by Dr Eleanor Maguire showed that London taxi drivers develop a
pumped-up hippocampus after years of doing the knowledge and navigating
the backstreets of the city. MRI scans showed that cabbies start off
with bigger hippocampuses than average, and that the area gets bigger
the longer they do the job. As driver David Cohen said at the time to
BBC News: "I never noticed part of my brain growing - it makes you
wonder what happened to the rest of it!"
Yet great breakthroughs
don't automatically translate into practical benefits. "Research may
give us great insights, but we still can't cure Alzheimer's," points out
neuroscientist Baroness Susan Greenfield. "And just because we know
more about what parts of the brain do normally, it doesn't tell us why
things go wrong. We still need to know why special cells die in
dementia. How come you can have a major stroke with lots of neuronal
damage, but not lose your memory? What is the link between Parkinson's
disease and dementia?" In other words, why are some cells damaged but
not others?
Lab-based research is key to piecing together the
jigsaw of how our brains work and what goes wrong when they don't. Even
scans or postmortem examinations of brains of people who had dementia
are of limited value, points out Greenfied, because "degeneration starts
10-20 years before symptoms appear". So what does neuroscience tell us about keeping the brain fit?
Professor John O'Keefe.Photograph: Facundo Arrizabalaga/EPAUse it or lose it It seems obvious that the more you train, use and test your brain, the better it will perform. There is some evidence that people with more education or skills have a lower incidence of dementia.
But the picture is complicated; perhaps highly educated people eat
better food. And more skilled people may be more likely to be in work,
benefiting from exercise, social interaction and mental stimulation. You
may build up a "cognitive reserve" while young, which gives you a
headstart over less educated people once dementia sets in. Staying
physically, mentally and socially active means that even if your brain
scan looks as ropey as that of a less active person, you will function
better. No one can confirm the benefits, but there is at least no
downside to daily sudoku, crosswords, reading, walks and talks.
Neuro-enhancing drugs Nootropics are also called smart drugs or cognitive enhancers. One of the best known is modafinil, a "wakefulness-promoting" drug
that stimulates the central nervous system and is only prescribable in
the UK for excessive daytime sleepiness (narcolepsy). Whether it is much
more effective than a strong cup of coffee remains debatable, but its
effect lasts longer. Modafinil is widely used by academics and students because it makes people feel sharper and more alert. Professor Barbara Sahakian of the University of Cambridge
has found that sleep-deprived surgeons perform better on modafinil, and
thinks it may have a wider role in improving our memory and mental
function. "We found that modafinil improves motivation and working
memory in healthy people and makes doing tasks more pleasurable," she
said. But long-term safety, especially for young brains, is still not
established. But for a lot of students, the question isn't whether the
drugs are safe or constitute cheating, but how they can get hold of
some.
Avoiding damage Our environment is full of
neurotoxins that can interfere with the genes, proteins and small
molecules that build and maintain our brains. The younger the brain, the
more susceptible it is to neurotoxins. A paper by the US National
Scientific Council on the Developing Child says there are three types of
neurotoxins that can affect the developing brain: environmental
chemicals such as lead, mercury and organophosphates (pesticides);
recreational drugs such as alcohol, nicotine and cocaine; and
prescription medications such as Roaccutane,
used for severe acne. Mature brains can be quite resilient, thanks in
part to a barrier of cells that restricts entry of chemicals from the
bloodstream into the brain tissue. But drugs, alcohol and cigarettes
will poison even the most developed of brains if you take enough of
them.
Keep the blood flowing The brain needs a
good blood flow to deliver vital nutrients and oxygen and take away
waste products. Smoking, high blood pressure, uncontrolled diabetes,
obesity and high cholesterol all sludge up the arteries and impede blood
flow. If you care about your brain function, sorting out these risk
factors remains the most useful thing you can do.
Effects of diet Omega-3 fatty acids, antioxidants such as vitamins C and E, and vitamins B and D all have neuroprotective effects, but
trials have failed to show that high-dose supplements of these
individual nutrients will protect you from dementia. However, eating a
tasty Mediterranean diet that combines most of these nutrients can't
hurt.
Future research Professor Sahakian has identified five areas of neuroscience research that will help our understanding over the next five years.
• Smart and wearable technology to monitor people's brain health - similar to wristband monitors that track heart rate.
• Brain scanning to monitor changes in mental illness and track changes during treatments such as CBT.
• Trials of neuroprotective drugs such as solanezumab to prevent further deterioration in patients with Alzheimer's disease.
• Connectomics, the study and production of connectomes - neural maps
of the brain - will combine a number of techniques to map and study
connectivity in the brain.
• Genetics, to understand the genetic mutations that contribute to autism and other conditions.
A brain ready for dissection. Photograph: Graeme Robertson/Guardian